| Tahun
|
Pemenang dan nominee
|
Penyunting
|
| 1996 |
Independence Day |
David Brenner
|
| The English Patient |
Walter Murch
|
| Fargo |
Roderick Jaynes
|
| Mission: Impossible |
Paul Hirsch
|
| Romeo + Juliet |
Jill Bilcock
|
| 1997 |
Titanic |
Conrad Buff dan Richard A. Harris
|
| Air Force One |
Richard Francis-Bruce
|
| Amistad |
Michael Kahn
|
| Boogie Nights |
Dylan Tichenor
|
| L.A. Confidential |
Peter Honess
|
| 1998 |
Saving Private Ryan |
Michael Kahn
|
| Beloved |
Carol Littleton
|
| Pleasantville |
William Goldenberg
|
| Shakespeare in Love |
David Gamble dan Christopher Greenbury
|
| The Thin Red Line |
Leslie Jones, Saar Klein, dan Billy Weber
|
| 1999 |
The Sixth Sense |
Andrew Mondshein
|
| American Beauty |
Tariq Anwar dan Christopher Greenbury
|
| Buena Vista Social Club |
Monica Anderson dan Brian Johnson
|
| The Insider |
William Goldenberg, David Rosenbloom, dan Paul Rubell
|
| Sleepy Hollow |
Chris Lebenzon dan Joel Negron
|
| The Talented Mr. Ripley |
Walter Murch
|
